Why Cafe de Leche matters.
Café de Leche is a neighborhood-rooted coffeehouse where Highland Park's Latino cultural character meets small-batch roasting, Nicaraguan family tradition and a pioneering York Boulevard café founded by Anya and Matthew Schodorf in 2008.
Set along York Boulevard near Avenue 50 and just steps from Arroyo Seco Regional Branch Library, the café occupies Highland Park's principal east-west commercial spine between the residential slopes rising toward Mount Washington and the foothills extending northeast toward Eagle Rock, with the Arroyo Seco cutting south toward the Los Angeles River. York Boulevard follows flat terrain through an early twentieth-century commercial district of modest one- and two-story storefronts whose development accelerated around streetcar service. FreelandBuck shaped the corner café around expansive windows and an elongated interior wall carrying an image of the San Fernando mountains, turning the long elevation into a graphic focal point. Angled counter and partition walls manipulate views across the narrow room, and a continuous bench expands seating. The result is a coffeehouse whose corner glazing, mountain-scale mural, compressed geometry and relationship with York Boulevard give the Schodorfs' neighborhood café a physical character inseparable from Highland Park.
What defines Cafe de Leche.
Café de Leche is best known for joining specialty coffee with the Nicaraguan family traditions of co-founder Anya Schodorf, who created the business with her husband Matthew in their adopted Highland Park neighborhood in 2008. Anya was born in Nicaragua, grew up in San José, Costa Rica and Glendale, and developed her earliest relationship with coffee through milk heated by her mother, Mamá Rosa, then mixed with instant coffee and sugar. Matthew was born in Ohio, grew up in Ventura and met Anya in Highland Park during the summer of 2001. Their café acquired its name during one of Mamá Rosa's visits from Nicaragua, when her request to Matthew, “Mateo pasame mi cafe de leche,” supplied the phrase that the couple adopted for the business. The Schodorfs financed the venture with their life savings and a loan against their house, and Matthew retained his work as a photo assistant as the new business struggled through its first years during the recession. Café de Leche opened in fall 2008 inside the 1966 Nogueira Building, where David Freeland developed what Matthew described before opening as a modern Central American interior appropriate to the surrounding working-class Latino community. The café joined The York, opened the previous year, among the early independent businesses associated with York Boulevard's subsequent commercial resurgence. Coffee roasting eventually moved directly into the Highland Park operation, making the original café home to the company's small-batch roastery as the business expanded elsewhere in Los Angeles.
Horchata con Espresso carries the founders' Latin American orientation most directly into the cup, joining espresso with the cinnamon-and-rice character of horchata in a drink associated with the Highland Park café since its opening year. Latte Campesino adds another Latin-inflected preparation to a contemporary selection that also includes Mexi Mocha, Chai Chata and matcha drinks. The coffee beneath those preparations is roasted in small batches in Highland Park, with the Water + Power espresso blend using washed beans at a medium-dark roast and developing baker's chocolate, caramel and nutmeg characteristics. Tranquilo decaf shifts to a medium roast and sugarcane process with chocolate-nib and sugarcane notes, demonstrating that decaffeination remains part of the roasting program. Single-origin offerings extend beyond blends: Chichiquila comes from Mexico's Puebla Coffees Project, receives a washed medium roast and develops chocolate-brownie and pomegranate characteristics. Espresso, cappuccino, cold brew and brewed coffee retain the conventional forms needed to expose those roast profiles directly, and hibiscus lemonade broadens the selection through a tart fruit preparation outside coffee. The combination places the Schodorfs' strongest cultural signatures beside an increasingly serious roasting program, connecting the family ritual behind the café's name with coffee selected and roasted under the same business nearly two decades later.
How Cafe de Leche fits.
Café de Leche works as the anchor for a Northeast Los Angeles outing connecting Charles Fletcher Lummis's hand-built Arroyo Seco residence, the hilltop museum he founded and a collection of rescued Victorian buildings preserving Southern California's nineteenth-century architecture.
Begin at Lummis Home, where journalist, preservationist and collector Charles Fletcher Lummis began constructing El Alisal in 1897 using stone gathered from the neighboring Arroyo Seco. Lummis spent 13 years building the house, incorporating heavy wooden doors and windows inset with photographic glass plates from his travels across the Southwest. The property became a center of the Arroyo cultural movement, gathering artists, writers and intellectuals around a building inseparable from its creator's interests in Southwestern history and culture. Continue to Southwest Museum, which Lummis founded through the Southwest Society and incorporated in 1907 as Los Angeles's first museum. The purpose-built Mount Washington complex opened in 1914 from a design by Sumner Hunt and Silas Burns combining Andalusian and Early California Mission influences with Moorish and medieval details in its tower. A Mayan-themed portal, tunnel and elevator followed in 1919, the Caroline Boeing Pool Wing of Basketry arrived in 1942 and the Braun Research Library was added in 1979 as the collections outgrew the original building. Conclude at Heritage Square Museum, where eight historic structures rescued from demolition preserve domestic and commercial architecture from Southern California's Victorian era. The museum has spent more than half a century acquiring and restoring buildings from different Los Angeles neighborhoods, assembling them on landscaped grounds to interpret the region's development during its first century of statehood. The progression moves from one man's hand-built Arroyo Seco home through the museum created from his collecting ambitions and culminates in a preservation campus where displaced Victorian buildings retain physical evidence of the Los Angeles that preceded Highland Park's modern commercial streets.
Where your story begins.
Foresyte Travel reveals places that feel extraordinary long before you arrive.
Enjoy editorial crafted for luxury travelers.
Foresyte may earn a commission when you book.
